the first chapter
of Ron Cole's doctoral dissertation, "The Electronic Valve Instrument:
Nyle Steiner's Unique Musical Innovation," submitted to the University
of Washington in June of 1998. It has been edited for use at this website.
The basic concept
that was to give birth to the Electronic Valve Instrument (EVI)1
began in 1964. Nyle Steiner, a trumpeter, music student, and engineering
employee at an electronics firm, envisioned an electronic string instrument in
which the string fingerings could be manipulated utilizing trumpet-fingering
technique. He states,
The technology
wasn't anything similar in those days but I had some ideas of making an
electronic device. I was going to make a tone by having a wire vibrate with
things pushed down on the string to lengthen or shorten it. I was trying to
figure out how to do the overtones on the wire.2
This project was
shelved in favor of the formation of Steiner-Parker Inc., a Salt Lake City based
partnership with fellow engineer Dick Parker, which began designing
keyboard-based synthesizers in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Steiner was
responsible for design of the electronic portion while Parker designed and built
the cabinetry and enclosures. Since Steiner was not a keyboard player, he
resurrected his concept of using a trumpet-based controller to manipulate a
synthesizer tone generator. His original goal was to create a synthesizer that
trumpet players could easily play without having to learn keyboard-fingering
technique. Steiner stated that,
The ultimate
thing in the beginning was to make a trumpet interface so that any trumpet
player could pick it up and say, "Hey, I can play the synthesizer
now." But that didn't turn out to be practical; it turned out to be
easier to learn some new techniques but have the instrument really be
powerful. So, in certain ways, if we try to imitate all of a trumpet we also
imitate some of its limitations.3
Development of
the EVI began in 1971, with the first prototype being produced the next year.4
Commercial availability began in 1975.5 Steiner estimates around 200
Steiner-Parker EVIs had been produced between 1975 and 1979, many of them having
been sold to university music departments and pop groups. He noted that,
We sold them
around the colleges and universities. I remember (the pop group) Earth, Wind
and Fire had one. They were one of the first systems we sold.
Columbia-Princeton University ordered a couple of them.6
The first EVIs
controlled only on/off tone generation in a dedicated synthesizer module,
initiated by blowing into the breath pipe of the instrument, which activated a
breath (air pressure) sensor. No air actually passed through the airtight
instrument; the performer actually allowed air to pass from the mouth around the
outside of the breath pipe to simulate the airflow through a wind instrument.
Octave selection was achieved via a rotating canister and thumb-rollers, and
pitch via three springed switches positioned to emulate trumpet valves.7
Toward the end of the 1970s, many of the added features associated with the
later EVI versions were incorporated into the design, including CV (control
voltage) directed volume via manipulation of air pressure at the breath sensor,
a vibrato sensor, a "bite sensor" for controlling a portamento effect,
and pitch bending plates (albeit retro-fitted by Steiner). Several commercially
available synthesizers were also interfaced for use with the EVI, such as the
Mellotron.8
Steiner-Parker
Inc. dissolved in 1979, and Steiner was left with the rights to the EVI. That
same year, he began a five-year relationship with Crumar, an Italian electronics
firm in the business of designing and marketing keyboard-based synthesizers. The
Crumar EVI, which debuted commercially in 1980, had all of the previously
mentioned features plus the benefits of larger manufacturing and marketing
resources, much more than Steiner and Parker had by themselves. The Crumar
instrument sold more than double the amount of the Steiner-Parker EVI, around
500 units.9 Toronto trumpeter Bruce Cassidy of the jazz-influenced
rock group Blood, Sweat and Tears made one of the earliest recordings using the
Crumar EVI.10
The debut of the
Musical Instrument Digital Interface (MIDI) specification in 1982 had enormous
repercussions throughout the world of electronic music, not the least of which
was the obsolescence of many makes of commercially marketed synthesizers. Some
pre-MIDI synthesizers were adapted for MIDI uses. J. L. Cooper Electronics
constructed MIDI adapter modules for several synthesizers, one of which was the
Lyricon, a wind controller using woodwind-fingering technique, which was popular
in the 1970s. Jim Cooper rewrote the software specifications of his Lyricon MIDI
adapter for the Crumar EVI’s accompanying synthesizer module, and Steiner
adapted the hardware interface. This allowed the Crumar EVI to transmit MIDI
note on and note off, aftertouch, pitchwheel (pitch bend), and breath control
(which could be used to control several effects, including volume). Los Angeles
based studio musician Judd Miller to this day continues to use this version.11
Crumar never incorporated these MIDI functions into its EVI model and, in fact,
never produced more than one model. Crumar ceased production of the EVI in 1984,
and discontinued operations entirely in 1987.12
However, during
his association with Crumar, Steiner continued to refine the EVI’s MIDI
functionality.
…and then I
[Steiner] started taking that (J. L. Cooper) box and added a feature here and
there and that grew into the system that we’ve got now. It's using the same
microprocessor. It was kind of like converting a garage into a high school.
You just keep banging a bit, adding, you know. That's the way the
microprocessor system all started. But, initially Jim Cooper rewrote the
software for the EVI but then you know, I couldn't just keep going back every
time I wanted something and say, ‘Hey, let's figure this out,’ because you
don’t have time to do that, so I finally disassembled the code and figured
out where everything was and just started from there and just kept adding a
piece at a time.13
As the Crumar EVI
was approaching discontinuation, Steiner not only continued refining his EVI
prototypes, but also began designing the EVI’s sister instrument, the
Electronic Woodwind Instrument (EWI), initially named the "Steinerphone."
This instrument was to be electronically almost identical to the EVI; the major
difference in design, of course, involving fingering. The EWI’s fingering
system originally was to be patterned after the basic pattern used by woodwinds.
However, due to the problem of fitting a great amount of switches in the body of
the instrument, Steiner replaced the switches with smaller touch keys. Touch
keys were open contacts in the circuitry, located to emulate woodwind keys, and
allowing the user to ground those contacts with the fingers, rather than closing
the circuit with a switch. Steiner pointed out that,
It was easier
to put a key right where you wanted it and make it the size you wanted it.
With the buttons (switches) you were stuck with the certain buttons that were
available, and the thing that really got me looking into that was when I made
the first woodwind instruments, because there were so many keys and little
side keys and there weren't any buttons you could do that with, and with
contacts, any size piece of metal could be a key. Then I thought, "Why
not do that with the EVI also."14
Accordingly,
Steiner began to fit his EVI prototypes with touch keys, trading the simulation
of a "valve stroke" using switches for more available space on the
instrument. The touch keys were placed in the same location on the instrument as
the springed switches, again emulating the placement of trumpet valves, and also
allowing space on the instrument for the possibility of additional keys. He took
advantage of this added space by creating trill keys. Trill keys were three
additional touch keys located to the side of each "trumpet" touch key,
within easy reach of the fingers. The function of the trill keys was to
alleviate certain awkward fingering combinations by creating alternate
fingerings, which would also allow easier trilling between certain notes.
A significant
improvement to the Crumar synthesizer module, again fashioned in a Steiner
prototype, was the "External In" port. This allowed the synthesizer to
manipulate the audio output of an external synthesizer, using many of the same
devices used to manipulate and edit the synthesizer’s resident sounds. For
example, varying air pressure at the EVI controller could control the volume of
the external sound source. Between the EVI prototype’s MIDI capabilities, and
those of the "External In" port, innumerable timbral variances were
possible.